The judgment in case of keck and mithouard 1995 1 cmlr 101 was designed to clarify this stance. Eurlex 61995j0368 en the full report for familia press. Why eu law claims supremacy oxford journal of legal. Judgment of the court of justice, keck and mithouard, joined cases c26791 and c26891 24 november 1993 author. Article 34 tfeu prohibits restrictions on the import of goods from other member states. As implied before, keck is third in a row of three court of justice of the european union cjeucjeu decisions, all dealing with the interpretation of article 34 tfeu. The text is easy to follow, with useful features throughout such as case summaries, key. In this case, it is important that there exist two groups of justifications treatybased and case law based.
Criminal proceedings against bernard keck and daniel. With a tradition dating back to 1885, the keck school of medicine of usc is the oldest school of medicine in southern california. The courts tendency to hold that differences between the rules in force in the various member states is problematic. The establishment and development of the european unions eu internal. These are notes for supervision 7 on the law of the european union oneninth of entire course.
Jan 19, 2011 the keck case refers to the free movement of goods between countries. Outline of the postkeck case law on certain selling arrangements case rule outcome c401 tankstation. The pelckmans judgment, delivered by the court of justice first chamber on 8 may 2014, marks a new stage of development in a long line of case law. Eu law, or european union law, concerns the law created by the european union. Eu supervision 7 notes goods ii law l100 cam studocu.
That reason is to be found in the judgment of 24 november 1993 in keck and mithouard, 21 in which the court to some extent altered its caselaw on article 30 of the ec treaty. The free movement of goods chapter 17 european union law. Cjeu decisions on tfeu article 34 in keck lawteacher. Building on its unrivalled reputation as the definitive eu text, cases, and materials book, this edition looks in detail at the way in which the treaty of lisbon has radically changed both the institutional and substantive law. Up until now, the case law on restrictions of the free movement of goods has been far more extensive and nuanced, especially with the distinction between product requirements and certain selling arrangements made in the famous keckdecision. Sunday trading csa not caught c391 commission v greece milk product sold only in pharmacies csa not caught. That reason is to be found in the judgment of 24 november 1993 in keck and mithouard, 21 in which the court to some extent altered its case law on article 30 of the ec treaty. Eventually the ecj declared that these rules could be justified by sociocultural reasons but by that point the uk parliament was already under huge pressure to change the law. Some authors guessed that with this case law the keck selling arrangements doctrine might have been consigned to history books. Joined cases c26791 and c26891, keck and mithouard, 1993. In its famous dasonville judgement from the mid 70s, the ecj interpreted art. Leaving keck behind the free movement of goods after the. As implied before, keck is third in a row of three court of justice of the european union cjeucjeu decisions, all dealing with.
A few years ago in trailers the ecj declined to extend keck to user arrangements and declared that a measure will be classified as a measure having. Citizenship is determined by evidence of an individuals intent to establish a permanent or indefinite domicile in a particular state, even if a reason for the move was to establish diversity of citizenship for federal jurisdiction. In particular, it focuses on the golden shares case law and seeks to investigate. According to the settled caselaw, all trading rules enacted by the member states which are capable of hindering, directly or indirectly, actually or potentially, trade within the eu are to be considered as measures having an effect equivalent to quantitative restrictions and are, on that basis, prohibited by article 34 tfeu. A brief and practical guide to eu law wiley online library. Free movement of goods prohibition of resale at a loss.
Paul is one of the foremost scholars on european law and administrative law and has published extensively in these areas. The case involved a french law which prohibited distributors reselling goods at a loss. Reference for a preliminary ruling in the criminal proceedings against bernard keck and daniel mithouard 1993 c26791 is an eu law case, concerning the. Eu free movement of workers information a summary of the way the eu deals with one of the most important rights conferred unto eu citizens the free movement of workers. Eu law directions explains the key topics and developments in this fastpaced and increasingly important subject area. In the same vein, in libro,44 the court ruled that book pricefixing45 of. This chapter examines the negative integration case law of the court of justice in the labour law field. Barnard, the substantive law of the eu 2014, at 656. Austrian law prohibiting austrian importers of germanlanguage books from fixing. Hi, this is how i understand the situation regarding meqrs and indistinctly applicable measures.
Reverse discrimination is not prohibited by eu law. Judgment of the court of justice, keck and mithouard, joined. Cjeu decisions on tfeu article 34 in keck law teacher. Contents 1 facts 2 judgment 3 see also 4 notes 5 references 6 external links facts sweden banned tv ads directed at children under age 12, and. The keck case refers to the free movement of goods between countries. Building on its unrivalled reputation as the definitive eu text, cases, and materials book, this edition looks in detail at the way in which the treaty of lisbon has radically changed both the institutional and substantive law of. The keck judgment is a classic of eu internal market law. Bri sh law required most shops to be closed on sundays. Redefining restrictions in the golden shares case law. Sweden banned tv ads directed at children under age 12, and banned. An academic text aimed at undergraduate students written in a similarly accessible style to eu concentrate. Evaluation of the keck formula in selling arrangements. The keck and mithouard case law of the cjeu constituted an important milestone in the effort to develop workable principles for the interpretation of article 34 tfeu in a way that would not jeopardize the ability of member states to regulate their economy and pursue other public policy objectives than promoting trade. The managers, messrs keck and mithouard, raised an argument that such prohibition runs afoul of what now is article 28.
Is the restriction necessary in a democratic society. However, with an increasing case load the courts attention seems to have gradually. A csa is to do with how the product is sold so if the law says shops will not open on sundays that would be a csa and would be acceptable under the keck formula, because it is about how the product is being sold i. Joined case c267, 26891, keck and mithouard 1993 ecr i6097. Case giving an example of a selling arrangement failing keck requirements restriction on advertising alcoholic drinks on tv and mags differed in fact.
Reference for a preliminary ruling in the criminal proceedings against bernard keck and daniel mithouard 1993 c26791 is an eu law case, concerning the conflict of law between a national legal system and european union law. Eu law fmg study guide by tomhewitson includes 98 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. Court of justice of the european union cjeu decisions on treaty on the functioning of the european union tfeu article 34 in kec example european law essay question. Advertising outside pharmacies csa not caught c412 leclerc siplec. Leading case on inspections by eu law not being cee charge was for covering vet fees for live animals. Cvce all rights of reproduction, public communication, adaptation, distribution or dissemination via internet, internal network or any other means are strictly reserved in all countries. Concerned the legality under eu law of a french law prohibiting the resale of goods in an unaltered state to prevent predatory pricing. His short case analysis of 1994 on the keck judgment is both amusing mr van gerven rightly felt. The court found that selling arrangements did not constitute a measure having equivalent effect to a quantitative. Since it prevents austrian importers and foreign publishers from fixing minimum retail prices according to conditions of import market whereas austrian publishers are free to fix. Any restrictions effect in the same manner in law and in fact, the marketing of both domestic and imported goods. The cjeus reasoning although not the result in keck is unsatisfactory for two reasons. Court considers it necessary to reexamine and clarify its caselaw on this matter.
Article 34 tfeu and certain selling arrangements law. Eu law, sunday trading restrictions and the charter. Element of eu lawdoes the case fall under eu free movement law. The court made clear that any measure which may impede access to the market. Keck notes prepared on selling arrangement keck studocu. Ecj case lawson on free movement of goods grades hero. In keck and mithouard 1993, the ecj dis nguished between 2 categories of na onal. Selling arrangements are circumstances of sale when, how, where and are not meqrs unless they.
Building on its unrivalled reputation as the definitive eu law textbook, this sixth edition continues to provide clear and insightful analysis of all aspects of european union law. In keck, criminal proceedings had been brought against a supermarket manager who had allowed products to be sold at a loss. Bernard keck and daniel mithouard cases c26726891 before the court of justice of the european communities ecj. Minimum price for books directly discriminatory csa discriminatory. The case decisions aim at eliminating national rules that hinder european integration through replacing the national laws with constructed eu level case laws. Interventions of the court of justice oxford scholarship. It has put a strain especially in relation to justification and proportionality on its case law in the labour law field. Their contention was that the sunday trading law reduced the overall volume of sales and. Judgment of the court of justice, keck and mithouard. This article deals with the keck and mithouard decision, not because changes in the case law of the court are especially rare in my ten years in office i have seen only four cases in which the court openly stated that intention, or because this case is somehow spectacular. However, that is not the chief reason for which the caselaw cited above cannot be applied simpliciter in this case. Case c29292 ruth hunermund and others v landesapothekerkammer badenwurttemberg 1993.
The sunday trading cases 18 5 keck and mithouard 20 6 postkeck cases 25 6. The european union was created on the principle to guarantee the free movement of goods, capital, services, and people within the eus 27 member states1. Two managers of the french hypermarkets selling goods at a loss were criminally charged. Selling arrangements are usually equal burden rules which, following the keck case, now fall outside of the scope of application of article 34 tfeu. However, that is not the chief reason for which the case law cited above cannot be applied simpliciter in this case. Austrian law provided in effect that an importer of books could not fix a price below retail price fixed or recommended by the publisher for the state of publication. Building on its unrivalled reputation as the definitive eu text, cases, and materials book, this edition looks in detail at the way in which the treaty of lisbon has radically. The bulk of the case law concerning free movement of goods can be. In the 1990s the european court of justice ecj established a distinction between the product requirements and certain selling arrangements in the case of keck and mithouard. Article 34 tfeu and certain selling arrangements law trove. For instance, ecjs decision in the case of dassoville ecj 874 outlined that measures that are capable of either directly or indirectly hindering eu common market have equivalent. A precedentsetting judgment on the free movement of goods.
Rhetorical devices are plentiful for the creative court. The facts of the case 9 concerned with french law prohibiting sale at a loss. If the discrimination deals in those types of situations then, it will be unlawful unless art 36 applies or, as per cassis, the. Criminal proceedings against bernard keck and daniel mithouard. In the keck judgment, the cjeu tried to clarify the scope of article 34 tfeu 28 ec. Text, cases, and materials provides clear and insightful analysis of all aspects of european law in the post lisbon era. The rule must apply to all traders in the territory, so that they are universally applicable. May 19, 2014 the pelckmans judgment, delivered by the court of justice first chamber on 8 may 2014, marks a new stage of development in a long line of case law. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Jan 08, 2014 a good example of this is the sunday trading case law which challenged the limits on sunday trading hours imposed in the uk. Read about our mission and vision, our history, distinguished activities, our history of community service, administrative and educational leadership.
Bernard keck and daniel mithouard cases c26726891 before. Based on 35 years experience teaching and examining european union eu law, this book provides a studentfriendly text which is readable without compromising on academic quality. Article 28 ec and contributions of the keck case law teacher. Keck formula selling arrangements would be excluded from the scope of art.
1426 774 832 519 1053 1548 1318 1480 1012 1306 1501 438 707 1574 750 912 767 1341 1602 850 972 220 1532 826 708 522 1209 319 686 1257 1325 1272